Ask BHP: What Changes Are Made to Covers?

Cover design is always a popular topic in our Ask BHP poll, and this reader wants to know: “I’d like to hear a little bit about the cover design process. Specifically, I know there’s a group that approves or asks for changes to covers. What are the most common things you change?”

At our first meeting, editorial and marketing representatives meet with our creative director to talk about their vision for the covers of that season’s books—usually about 15-16. All will have read the synopsis (the book is rarely finished at this point), and they’ll bring covers they really like or other visual aids. The creative director, Paul Higdon, then translates this feedback to the designers.

For the next stage, the team is mostly looking at pencil sketches or stock photo approximations of what the poses for a cover might look like, especially when there will be a photoshoot of one or more models. This is the point to say, “Wait, that’s a totally different direction than the first two books in the series,” or “I think the silhouette is a better idea than the split-scene” or “Let’s be sure to have her outdoors instead of inside.”

Later, after many hundreds of hours of work on photoshoots and Photoshop, the designer will present a semi-final version of the cover…actually, usually 6-10 different versions. Some are in totally different styles and tones, others are similar with smaller variations on the type or model pose. We’ll give another round of feedback, this time more specific as to what we like or don’t like, voting on our favorite designs.

One of our designers, Jenny Parker, said, “The designers probably have the best idea of what an author goes through, because we have our art critiqued by others—sometimes while we’re in the room! Then it’s time to take that feedback and make changes.”

And that’s a hard task, especially because most of us have vague instincts like, “That type is hard to read” or “something about that model’s expression looks unpleasant” or “the color pallet just seems off.” They might be true statements, but the designer has to find the way forward to actually do what the team members are suggesting.

Once we agree on the right design (or a Franken-combo of designs), there are still tweaks to be made. At the near-final stage, here are some recent comments jotted down in meeting notes.

  • Check with the author to make sure those earrings are appropriate for the time period. It might be fine.
  • I’m not loving the series logo…can we get rid of some of the froufy frilly things around the text?
  • The woman’s dress is really close to the blue dress of the first book in the series. Let’s make it more teal, or a different color altogether.
  • Will the author like this? Because it’s a very different direction than what we’ve done for her in the past.
  • So…no one else thinks the guy in the background on Cover 3 looks creepy? (Consensus: we did not go with Cover 3.)
  • Let’s make sure to get her hair a little darker. It’s edging toward blond, and she clearly has light brown hair from the character description.
  • The author’s name should be in a thicker type to make it easier to read.
  • Does the pose look like a “strong, independent woman” or just over-the-top to you?

Then…more designer magic happens, and the final cover is sent to the author for feedback, as well as to members of our sales team for approval. Once everything is set to go, it gets placed in our catalog, the one that the sales team uses when presenting to bookstores (usually 8-10 months before release).

Here are some examples of those middle stages in the process. For Tracie Peterson’s new series (releasing in March 2019), our creative team asked if Jenny could have a large face above Western scenery as a way to set the series apart. Here are a few of the options we saw.

…but interestingly enough, Jenny put in a few designs with a totally different feel, trying to imitate a Wild West poster. Everyone loved that direction, even though it was different than what we had originally suggested. We had different poses to choose from in that design, and this is the one we went with after a few tweaks, the final cover of When You Are Near.

So there you have it, a small glimpse into the world of book cover design. Hope you enjoyed it!

What’s a cover that stood out to you recently? It can be in any genre.

10 thoughts on “Ask BHP: What Changes Are Made to Covers?

  1. I think Shelter of the Most High (C. Cossette) is just stunningly gorgeous! I kept closing the book while reading to look at it again and again. The colors are so beautiful!

  2. Well, these aren’t recent, but I loved Kristi Ann Hunter’s A Noble Masquerade (color and styling), and Sarah Sundin’s When Tides Turn (really captured the personalities). Those two came to mind immediately, but there are so many beautiful covers, I could list ones all day.

  3. Lady of a Thousand Treasures by Sandra Byrd is stunning. Lady Jayne Disappears by Joanna Politano captures the mystery. My favorite series covers are Rosanna White’s Ladies of the Manor series, Shadows Over England and the new series with Margo. I also like Kristi Ann Hunter’s Hawthorne House series and Carolyn Millers covers. There are so many grear covers!
    I like the final one for the example you showed.

  4. Love’s reckoning by Laura Frantz , Deep in the heart of trouble by Deeanne Gist and The mark of the King by Jocelyn Green, beautiful covers.

  5. I am LOVING the Bethany House summer 2019 cover reveals! Karen Witemeyer’s is my favorite!!

    I like the covers for Mary Connealy’s Cimarron Legacy series…they’re laid out really well and I love the sunsets!

    Lately, I think the pinks/purples used on some recent romantic suspense titles have been really great!

    This was a fun post!! Thanks for sharing!

  6. I am another “Shelter of the Most High” by Connilyn Cossette and “Lady of a Thousand Treasures” by Sandra Byrd fan. Though whenever I hear the words “favorite cover”, I think of “The Pursuit of Tamsen Littlejohn” by Lori Benton.

  7. What a fun post! I enjoy learning more about the evolution of covers, and Bethany House covers are so beautiful. You have such talented designers!

  8. Pingback: How Book Cover Development Happens | Christian Book Shop Talk

  9. I thoroughly agree that the cover is very important. I am the librarian at our church library with over twelve thousand items available for check out. Over the years I have observed that if the cover is not attractive or exciting no one is interested in checking it out. I once had a series of 3 books, they were mysteries, but they had really creepy covers and no one would check them out. I decided to read them even though they were not my favorite genre. They were great. I put the word out and finally everyone
    was reading them. They were afraid of those creepy covers that really didn’t even represent very well what the books were about. Keep up the good work on those fabulous Bethany House covers. Love your books.

  10. Pingback: Ask BHP: How Does the Cover Design Process Work? – Bethany House Fiction

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.