Ask Bethany House: How Does a New Author Get Noticed?

When I asked for responses to our Ask Bethany House survey (which you can feel free to add to—all questions welcome!), the overwhelming majority had to do with how a new author might get a publishing contract with us. Apparently we have a lot of writers out there among our readers!

If you read our submission policy, you’ll know that you can’t just send us your manuscript, but our acquisition editors do seek out and give contracts to new and talented authors. Obviously, every writer’s story is going to be different—ask any of our authors, and you’ll find that out. But here are the two main ways our editors typically find new authors: through conferences and agents.



Writing conferences are a cross between boot camp (tons of intensive training) and summer camp (lots of fun with writer friends—and if you don’t already have writer friends, you will by the time the conference is over). Besides taking seminars on craft and voice and marketing, at most conferences, you’ll also have a chance to set up short meetings with agents and acquisition editors to pitch your book. If they’re interested, the agent or editor might request more information about your book, or even the whole manuscript. It’s one of the main ways new writers can get their work in front of Bethany House editors.

Even if you don’t walk away from a conference with a contract, it’s a great way to get feedback and advice to strengthen your writing. You won’t often find so many knowledgeable people in the same place, so take advantage of it! Make connections, find a critique partner, and hone your skills so you’re ready for a future opportunity.

And yes, writing conferences can seem expensive (although given the fact that you’re getting the equivalent of a college-level course on writing and getting published, I’d say they’re quite a bargain). But when our editors meet writers at a conference, it’s an easy way to know that these people are serious about writing. They’re investing time and money into improving their craft. That means their manuscript is going to be worth taking a look at.

Also, I’m told conferences are a lot of fun. (I’ll be at the ACFW conference for the first time this year, teaching a course on marketing with Melissa Tagg, so I’ll report back on just how much fun they can be. Stay tuned.)


This sounds like a super elite, Hollywood type of deal, but really it’s much simpler than that. Essentially, agents are go-betweens for the author with publishing companies. An agent will represent an author whose work they think has potential. (For their effort, they get a percentage of the money you make from the book once it sells.) They will then pitch the manuscript to the acquisition editors. Since the editors know that the agents are familiar with the business and would only accept talented authors, they’re willing to take a look at the proposals agents send them.

So, how does a writer go about getting an agent? That is a much longer topic than I have time to fully address in this blog post. But here’s a place to start: take a look at your favorite authors, ones who write stories similar to the ones you’re writing and are published at houses you’d love to break into, and see who their agents are. (Tip: agencies are often listed on authors’ websites.) You can also take a look at online databases that list reputable literary agencies.

Then take a look at those agents’ websites. What kind of books are they looking for? How much of the manuscript needs to be complete before they’ll consider it? What information do they need in a proposal, and how do they want it submitted? Carefully read through all of this information before deciding to submit a proposal to an agent.

Final Notes

Do. Your. Research. This is the single most important part of finding a publishing company or agent that will be a good fit for you. It does not matter how adorable your rhyming Bible princess storybook is if you pitch it to a publisher who doesn’t accept children’s books (hint: BHP is one of those). The same is true of agents—they will list on their website the genres they accept, so be sure to take the time to find out what those are.

As I mentioned before, there are other routes to publication. Sometimes one of our editors serves as a judge in a writing contest and takes note of an especially well-written manuscript. (If you’re wondering what contests are out there, let me refer you to the lovely ladies of Seekerville, including BHP’s own Mary Connealy, who do a great job of putting together contest roundups.) Sometimes a published author might read your manuscript and recommend you to her editor or agent. Sometimes you might send your proposal to Bethany House wrapped in plastic inside a giant cake. (Just kidding—don’t do that. Or if you do, make sure it’s chocolate.) Hopefully, though, this post helped clear up a few details about the process of publication.

For all you writers out there (or just readers interested in hearing how these things work), next month I’ll be asking one of our acquisition editors what makes an unknown writer’s manuscript stand out. Looking forward to it! And who knows, maybe someday I’ll be promoting your book on the blog!

9 thoughts on “Ask Bethany House: How Does a New Author Get Noticed?

  1. Wonderful post, Amy! I couldn’t agree more when you said every author’s publication story is different. I haven’t met any two authors with the same story. However, many of those stories include conferences, contests, or agents. My first ACFW Conference was like a dream. It was so much fun to meet authors I knew from their books–and those I didn’t. You do come away with dozens and dozens of new friends. I can’t wait to see you there next time!

    I would like to add that it sounds daunting to pitch your story to agents and editors, but when you get past the nerves, it is a blast talking with them. They’re usually very kind and understanding, and they truly want to know about you and your writing. Don’t look at the experience as the beginning and end of your journey–look at it as a stepping stone on the way. I’ve made wonderful connections in my pitching appointments–some led to publication, and others led to friendships–but all of them helped me become a better writer, and that’s really what it’s all about.

    • Thanks, Gabrielle! Glad to get an insider’s endorsement of the ACFW conference…I know I’m going to enjoy it!

      And especially thanks for the encouragement to other writers. That’s great advice, and probably quite reassuring to hear. I work with our editors and know that they aren’t scary–but I’m sure they can seem that way when it comes time to pitch a manuscript to one of them. Appreciate you, Gabrielle!

      Amy Green
      BHP Fiction Publicist

  2. Thank you for such an encouraging post. It made my day to hear that contests are a potential way of getting noticed by an editor. I’ve just entered 3 Christian fiction contests this month. I was nervous–but I won’t have a chance if I don’t take a risk.

    Blessings ~ Wendy ❀

    • I’m glad you enjoyed the post, Wendy. And good for you, entering those contests! I know it’s such a huge step to take, and often a terrifying one.

      Amy Green
      BHP Fiction Publicist

  3. Pingback: Ask Bethany House: How Do You Decide on a Book Cover? | Bethany House Fiction

  4. Hello Amy,

    Wow; what encouragement to find that really can be a way!

    I have a question. I am a newly published author through the Christian publishing company Covenant Books. ‘Choir Boy’ just became available through Amazon and Barnes and Nobles, both online. It was amazing to have ‘Choir Boy’ approved, and I am so very, very grateful for Covenant’s level of side by side service throughout the whole process.

    There are two series that I have been working on for years, both Christian. The one series is best described as a story line similar to Janette Oke’s ‘Love Comes Softly’, and Patricia MacLachlan‘s ‘Sarah, Plain and Tall,’ with hints of plot that may remind readers of a new spin on ‘Anne of Green Gables’ as well.

    I would absolutely love to get these books looked at by an agent who would and could connect me with Bethany.

    What suggestions can you give as to who I could best reach for assistance here?

    Any suggestions are greatly appreciated!


    • Hi Kelsie,

      I’m so glad you enjoyed the post! As for tips for connecting with a Bethany House editor, it really is the same as it was when I wrote this post four years ago. If you have an agent in the Christian market, they will certainly know who to pitch to here at Bethany House. I can’t directly recommend agents, but one tip is to see who represents some of the authors who write similarly to you. (Agents are often listed on the copyright page, or in the author’s acknowledgements.) Their websites will often provide information about how to send a query to them with information about your manuscript.

      Otherwise, signing up for an in-person appointment at a conference is by far the best way to present your manuscript to an editor here. (Northwestern Christian Writing Conference and the ACFW conference are two our fiction editors attend consistently, though there may be others in a given year, always check the faculty page of a conference.) I hope that’s helpful!

      Amy Green
      BHP Fiction Publicist

Leave a Reply to bethanyfiction Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.