Ask Bethany House: Why Traditional Publishing?

Welcome to this month’s edition of Ask Bethany House! I’m Amy Green, the fiction publicist here, and I’ve been answering some FAQs submitted via our survey. (Next month, we’ll be doing a post of interest to aspiring writers—be sure to check back!)

Question: In the modern era, when anyone can self-publish, what are the benefits of working with a publisher?

Answer: This question is kind of like asking the local Downtown Café owner why there is still a need for coffee shops when anyone can get a Keurig. First, the person answering has a pretty significant bias. But, second, bias aside, there are still good reasons for the more traditional option to exist.

I want to start off by saying that I have nothing against authors who self-publish. (I also, incidentally, have nothing against Keurigs.) Self-publishing can be a great option depending on your goals, but it’s also an area I am not equipped to talk about. There are lots of bloggers and indie writers out there with great information about the process of and merits to independent or self-publishing, so I’d advise taking a look at them to balance out your perspective. I’m not trying to say that traditional publishing is the best option in every situation, or that it has no downsides. I’m only saying that traditional publishing has many benefits, and that it’s by no means irrelevant.

Like the coffee shop owner, I recognize that my answer will be biased, but I hope it’s helpful anyway. (And that you’re now in the mood for a nice caramel latte to sip as you read the rest of this post.)


Here are three reasons I think traditional publishing matters in a self-publishing world.

Because Traditional Houses Have Greater Reach

Practically, if you want to see your book in brick-and-mortar stores, traditional publishing is the way to go, because A. physical stores have a limited space for inventory and B. buyers for LifeWay or Family Christian or Barnes & Noble or the independent stores trust that the books from Bethany House will be high-quality Christian fiction. We have a reputation with them.

Beyond retail stores, the same principle applies with bloggers, media contacts, and ad reps. Traditional publishers (and their corresponding promotional budgets and databases of reviewers and staff members dedicated to marketing books) can do more to get books noticed.

Because Anyone Can Self-Publish

In the early years of self-publishing, it was easier to get attention for lower-priced, self-published ebooks because not very many people were giving it a try. Now, the marketplace is very, very crowded. As I said, some of those participating are very talented authors…and others are that guy down the street who didn’t pass high school English but always wanted to write “a book about crime or something, like Stephen King.” And it’s getting increasingly difficult to tell the difference.

Readers know a traditionally published book will be of high quality in every way. They don’t have to take a chance on an unknown, because Bethany House already did that by searching through hundreds of unpublished manuscripts to find the ones we wanted to publish.

It’s hard to be noticed when you’re one small voice in a crowd of screaming people. The benefit of traditional publishing is that we give authors a microphone, a sound system, and a stage.


I love Snoopy’s view of the writing life.

Because I Want Authors to Focus on Writing

This, to me, is the most important benefit of traditional publishing.

At Bethany House, we emphasize to our authors over and over again that their primary job is to be a writer, not a marketer. I am a fiction publicist. I am paid to market books—they are paid to write beautiful, compelling stories.

When they self-publish, authors are writers, but they must also be marketers, and sometimes editors and designers, spending as much time and effort or more on selling their work as they do creating it. Many authors aren’t willing to do this, either because they don’t enjoy marketing or because they just don’t have the time.

Indie and self-published authors do an incredible amount of detailed, behind-the-scenes work, sometimes filling the roles of a dozen employees here at Bethany House (or hiring freelancers to serve in those roles). That’s amazing, but it’s also true that they are more qualified for some of those roles than others. And they only have so many hours in a day in which to do everything.

Our authors know they have a team of professionals with decades of experience behind them to do the big things, like designing their covers, editing their manuscripts, placing ads in magazines, and pitching books to media—as well as the little things, like creating book signing posters, fact-checking tiny details, issuing shut-down notices to people pirating ebooks online, and writing blog posts answering reader questions about traditional publishing.

That way, our authors can focus on writing that next book.

Remember, if you have a question or two you’d like to see answered in this series, submit it to our survey!

14 thoughts on “Ask Bethany House: Why Traditional Publishing?

  1. Another reason to embrace traditional publishing: Editors! Editors who see my book with a clear mind . . . Editors who make my writing shine . . . Editors who do things like delete ellipses ( . . . ). There’s nothing better for an author than working with a team dedicated to making her book as good as it can possibly be. I really love writing for Bethany House. Can you tell? 🙂 🙂

    • YES! Someone just asked me the other day if I edit my own books. My response was something like, “No, thank the Lord.” 🙂 I mean, sure, I self-edit before turning it in but I can’t imagine sending it into the world without the expertise of editors.

      • Love this! I didn’t want to over-emphasize the editing thing in the post, because I was afraid people would read it as, “Our authors really need help making their stuff presentable,” and all of you guys would be offended. But I guess I shouldn’t have worried!

        Amy Green
        BHP Fiction Publicist

  2. “At Bethany House, we emphasize to our authors over and over again that their primary job is to be a writer, not a marketer. I am a fiction publicist. I am paid to market books—they are paid to write beautiful, compelling stories.”

    And I am so, SO thankful for that! 🙂

  3. I appreciate everything about traditional publishing that you’ve mentioned, Amy. Plus, I echo Victoria’s sentiment. The editors! Oh, the editors. They’re the behind-the-scenes unsung heroes. My editors partner with me on every manuscript. They help me improve my work and I trust and respect and value them.

    Self-publishing has given authors options. I think it’s wonderful that there’s now more than one way to get a story into the hands of readers. Keurigs and coffee shops both have their merits!

  4. Very cool article. I self published my first novel just to get some feedback. It was a tremendous success. However, I will never self publish again. I hate having to focus on marketing as opposed to writing. That’s the main thing. I love to write. That takes time. When I have to be consumed with marketing, I don’t have the time I need for writing.

  5. I’ve never self-published, but I have a few small press books from a tiny company that does very little marketing. I’ve been blown away already by the difference of working with Bethany House. It’s been a real pleasure, and doors that were bolted tight before are now flying open to welcome me.

  6. Yes, the editors! No matter how carefully I read or reread my own manuscripts, I never catch everything. It’s a true blessing to have experienced people to see my work with fresh eyes and an outside perspective so I end up saying what I mean to say rather than what I thought I said at three in the morning. 😉

    And I have to say Bethany House has the most delicious covers and the very nicest people to work with. Jackpot!

    • Michael, in a way you’re right. Traditional publishers are limited because they can only publish so many books per year, and only a few of those spots are available to new authors. That’s just the nature of traditional publishing. I’m glad that other options exist, and I can see pros and cons to all of them.

      Amy Green
      BHP Fiction Publicist

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.